top of page
חלל אלקטרוניקה פתוח בגיטרה עם פוטנציומטרים וקבל

Pickups and Guitar Electronics

6 days ago
8 min read

Even with the volume and tone knobs on 10, the electronics in a passive guitar or bass still affect the sound and the signal level. The volume pot, the component the knob turns, stays connected to the pickup, along with the cable. The tone circuit also stays connected whenever the wiring connects it to the selected pickup. The selector switch mainly determines what's connected in each position.

Before replacing a pickup, pot or capacitor, work out exactly what you want to change. You can do most of these checks without opening up the instrument.

Simple Checks Before Replacing Parts

  • Does it sound dark even with the knobs on 10? Plug straight into the amp on a clean channel. Compare a short and a long cable of the same model, without changing the selector position or the amp settings.

  • Thinking about changing the tone capacitor? Play the same phrase with the tone on 10, 7, 4 and 0. Notice where in the knob's travel the sound changes, and whether you're missing a different sound specifically with the tone fully down.

  • Do the highs disappear when you turn down the volume? Try 10, 7 and 5, once clean and once with your usual drive. That way you'll know whether the loss of highs bothers you before you decide on a treble bleed, wiring that keeps more of the highs as the volume goes down.

  • Crackles or dropouts? Plug a cable you know is good straight into the amp. Check whether the noise appears only when you turn a knob, move the selector, or gently wiggle the plug in the jack. Whatever action makes the noise gives you a clue where to look for the fault.

  • One pickup too weak or too loud? Measure and write down its distance from the strings before you touch the screws. Adjust the height a quarter turn at a time, play and compare. If there's no improvement, go back to the original height before replacing any electronics.

How the Electronics Change the Sound

A passive pickup connected to the guitar and a cable can have a boost in a certain range of the highs. This boost is called the resonant peak. In a guitar with a regular cable it might appear, for example, around 2-5 kHz. That's a typical range, not a fixed rule. Above the peak, the highs roll off.

Capacitance, an electrical property the cable adds to the circuit, affects where the peak sits. The higher the total capacitance, the lower the peak moves in frequency and the darker the sound tends to be. The pot values mainly affect how pronounced the peak is. Lower values put a heavier load on the pickup, damp the peak and reduce the sparkle.

Think of it as a side opening in a pipe. A 250kΩ pot is like a bigger opening than a 500kΩ pot. In standard wiring, even with the knobs on 10, the opening never closes completely. That's why the pots still affect the sound.

250kΩ and 500kΩ Pots

The load is the combined effect of the components connected to the pickup. Here's an example of the resistive part of the load around the resonant peak, with one volume pot and one tone pot connected to the selected pickup, both on 10, and an amp input resistance of about 1MΩ:

  • 250kΩ volume and tone: A total load of about 110kΩ.

  • 500kΩ volume and tone: A total load of about 200kΩ.

These numbers are approximations for those conditions. The lower the frequency, the less the tone circuit affects it.

  • 250kΩ: A common starting point for Strat- and Tele-style single coils, when the goal is to smooth out the highs.

  • 500kΩ: A common choice for humbuckers and many P90s. A P90 is also a single coil, but it's usually warmer and louder than a Strat- or Tele-style single coil.

These are conventions, not laws. A dark single coil can sound better with 500kΩ, and a bright humbucker can sound better with 250kΩ. On an HSS guitar, meaning a bridge humbucker and two single coils, you can wire the instrument so each pickup type gets a different load. The coil's DC resistance, listed in specs as DCR, isn't a direct measure of a pickup's output.

Actual Value and How the Knob Responds

Tolerance is the allowed deviation from the value marked on the component. For example, a pot marked 500kΩ with a 20% tolerance can measure anywhere between 400kΩ and 600kΩ. The difference can be audible.

The taper determines how much change you get in each part of the knob's travel. Two knobs can sound the same on 10, but on one the change is spread across the rotation, while on the other most of it is packed into a short stretch.

The Tone Capacitor

The tone capacitor is the component that lets the tone circuit cut mainly the highs. The more you roll the tone down, the more the capacitor comes into play. On the same instrument, with the tone fully down, 0.047µF will usually sound darker than 0.022µF.

In a standard tone circuit, the pot and the capacitor stay connected even on 10. A no-load pot disconnects the tone circuit when it reaches 10. The volume knob stays active.

As for capacitor type, whether paper-in-oil, film or ceramic, what counts is the actual capacitance. When you compare healthy capacitors with the same measured value, there's no solid basis for an audible difference between the materials in a standard passive tone circuit. If two capacitors with the same printed value sound different, it's worth checking whether their actual values differ.

What the Cable Changes

A guitar cable adds capacitance, usually around 100 picofarads per meter (about 30 pF per foot), depending on the model. A 6-meter (20 ft) cable adds roughly twice the capacitance of a 3-meter (10 ft) cable of the same model. The longer cable lowers the frequency of the peak, so the guitar may sound less bright.

A buffer passes the signal on without the cables after it loading the pickup directly. What matters is where the first buffer sits in the signal path, not necessarily which pedal comes first. The cable between the guitar and the buffer still has an effect.

Why the Highs Drop When You Turn Down the Volume

In standard passive wiring, the volume knob and the cable affect the sound together. When you turn the volume down, it's not only the level that drops. Some of the highs fade too.

A treble bleed is a small capacitor, sometimes paired with a resistor, that lets some of the highs through even when you turn the volume down. It can also change how the level drops across the knob's travel, so the component values are matched to the instrument and to how you use the knob. Some players like the natural darkening, and others prefer to clean up their drive with the volume knob without losing brightness.

Bypass for a Solo Boost

A bypass sends the signal from the pickup straight to the output jack, without passing through the volume and tone controls. It can be engaged with a separate switch or a push-pull knob, a knob you pull up to flip a switch.

With the controls out of the circuit, the pickup is still connected to the cable and the amp input, but the load on it is lighter. The resonant peak stands out more, and the sound gets brighter, with more presence and more output. The difference is especially noticeable on single coils that are normally wired to 250kΩ pots.

Bypass always raises the output a little, but with the guitar's volume at maximum and a light picking touch, the difference is barely noticeable. You mainly hear it when you dig in hard.

We recommend trying bypass as a solo boost. Play rhythm with the regular wiring and engage the bypass when the solo comes in. In this mode, the guitar's volume and tone knobs have no effect. Check in advance that the jump in level suits your amp and pedals.

Reliability of Controls, Wiring and Connections

Selector Switch, Wires and Solder Joints

A healthy selector switch has almost no effect on the sound. Dirty or worn contacts can cause crackles or dropouts in certain positions. The wires inside the guitar are short, and their effect on the sound is much smaller than that of the external cable. Shielded wire, meaning wire with a jacket that helps reduce interference, adds a little capacitance.

A good solder joint doesn't improve the sound, but a poor one can cause crackles and dropouts, right away or later on. Holding the iron on too long while soldering can damage a pot, and a poor ground connection, meaning a faulty connection to the circuit's ground point, can cause noise.

Hand Wiring and Printed Circuit Boards

A printed circuit board (PCB) is a board in which metal traces replace some of the wires. A well-designed, well-assembled PCB prevents most of these wiring problems from the start, thanks to short, tidy connections that are identical in every unit. Careful hand wiring with suitable components can be just as reliable, and it gives more flexibility to tailor the wiring to the instrument and the player.

Sealed Pots

Most guitar pots, including good, well-known models, are built around a carbon track in an unsealed housing, a design that hasn't changed fundamentally since the 1950s. Over time, dust and moisture get in, the track wears, and crackles appear.

In Vergatto build electronics we use modern sealed CTS pots with a conductive-plastic track, the inner surface the contact slides along when you turn the knob. A sealed housing protects the component from dust and moisture, and the parts require no maintenance. CTS offers sealed versions rated up to IP67, a protection rating against dust and water ingress, depending on the model.

Durability figures published by CTS, in rotational cycles:

  • CTS 282 series, conductive-plastic track: 2,000,000 cycles.

  • CTS 284 series, conductive-plastic track: Up to 3,000,000 cycles.

  • CTS 450G series, guitar pot with a carbon track: 100,000 cycles.

  • CTS 18VRG series, guitar pot with a carbon track: 15,000 cycles.

Why the Same Pickup Sounds Different in Two Instruments

  • Electronics values: The actual values of the pots and the capacitor affect what you hear.

  • Pickup position: The distance from the bridge changes which parts of the string's sound the pickup picks up.

  • Scale length: The string length between the nut and the bridge affects its tension and how it vibrates, but it doesn't determine the instrument's sound on its own.

  • Bridge, construction and strings: All of them affect how the string vibrates.

  • Pickup height: Changing the distance from the strings can change the output, the response to your picking and the balance between pickups.

When an Electronics Upgrade Makes Sense

An electronics upgrade won't turn one pickup into another. It can match the pot and capacitor values to the pickup, give the knobs a response that feels better when you play, or add options like bypass, treble bleed and no-load.

  • When you change pickups: Especially when moving between single coils and humbuckers, check whether the existing pot values suit the sound you're after.

  • When there's noise, crackling or dropouts: Find the source of the problem first. If only the jack or a single pot is faulty, you can replace just that part.

  • When the knobs act like "all or nothing": A different taper can give more gradual control.

If the components are healthy, the values suit the pickups, and you're happy with the sound and how the knobs respond, there's no need to upgrade.

Electronics Options at Vergatto

Vergatto Build Electronics

A system we hand-wire in-house with sealed CTS pots. You can order it with any of our pickups and ask for options such as bypass, treble bleed or custom wiring. Most of these options come at no extra cost.

ObsidianWire System

The ObsidianWire system, from a New Zealand company, is a complete wiring system that comes pre-assembled (Pro-Wired), not a printed circuit board. The pickup leads connect to it with solderless connectors, so it's easy to swap pickups later.

According to the manufacturer, components vary between kits. The systems include CTS pots, and kits that include a selector switch use Oak or Schaller switches. Before ordering, we check the instrument model and the pickup configuration. We only offer the system when the manufacturer states it's compatible with the instrument and the configuration.

Installation and Warranty

When you have us do the installation, we install the pickups and electronics, set the pickup heights and play-test the instrument. With an order that includes installation, you can get trade-in credit for the old pickups that come out of the instrument.

All our pickups come with a 5-year warranty against manufacturing and assembly defects.

You can browse our Strat-style pickups, Telecaster-style pickups and humbuckers, and ask us via the WhatsApp button on the site which electronics suit your guitar.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page