top of page

Why Two Pickups With the Same DC Resistance Can Sound Completely Different

Feb 15
4 min read

Updated: 6 days ago

DC resistance is often the first number players look at when comparing pickups. It's the reading you get when you connect a multimeter to the pickup's leads, usually given in kilo-ohms. A reading of 6.0 kΩ means 6,000 ohms. It's tempting to read 6 kΩ as "vintage and low output" and 14 kΩ as "hot and aggressive."

That shortcut can be useful when you're comparing versions of the same pickup wound with the same wire. Across different designs, two pickups with the same reading can sound quite different. One might sound bright and open, the other warmer and fuller.

What DC resistance measures

Two things matter most when you're comparing the copper wire in pickup coils:

  • Wire length. The longer the wire, the higher the resistance. In the same coil design, adding turns means using more wire.

  • Wire thickness. Thinner wire has more resistance per metre. For example, 43 AWG wire is thinner than 42 AWG.

Wire thickness is the easiest reason to miss when you're looking at a spec sheet. In otherwise similar coils, the one wound with thinner wire can reach the same resistance with fewer turns. Fewer turns tend to produce less output if the rest of the design stays the same. An equal reading doesn't mean the pickups have the same number of turns, and it isn't a direct measure of output or tone.

What inductance changes

Inductance describes how strongly a coil opposes changes in electrical current. It depends on the number of turns, the shape of the coil and the materials in and around it, including the magnet, pole pieces and other steel parts.

Together with the cable and the guitar's controls, inductance helps determine where the pickup's treble emphasis sits. With the same cable and control settings, higher inductance tends to shift that emphasis lower. That can sound fuller and less sparkly. Two pickups that both read 8 kΩ can have quite different inductance.

The treble peak and your cable

A passive pickup connected to a cable and controls can emphasise a band of frequencies before the highest frequencies start to fade. That bump is called the resonant peak. A peak higher up in frequency tends to sound brighter. A lower one tends to sound warmer. The volume and tone controls and the amp input affect how much that peak stands out. In some setups, it's barely noticeable.

Capacitance is the ability to store electrical charge. Both the coil and the cable contribute to it, but the cable usually adds more than the coil itself. A longer cable of the same model adds more capacitance, which tends to move the peak lower.

Why coil shape matters

A typical Strat pickup has a tall, narrow coil. A traditional P90 has a wider, flatter one. Coil shape affects inductance, and the magnet and pole pieces help determine how the pickup senses the vibrating string. Those design differences are part of why a Strat pickup and a P90 can sound distinct even when their resistance readings overlap.

Hand winding and machine winding

The way the turns sit next to each other affects the coil's own capacitance. A more scattered winding pattern can lower it, but the pattern matters more than whether the wire is guided by hand or by machine. The cable usually has a bigger effect on total capacitance. Neither winding method guarantees a better sound.

What the magnet changes

Changing the magnet can change a pickup's output and tone without changing the coil's DC resistance. Alnico II designs often have a softer attack and a warmer sound. Alnico V designs can feel tighter and more defined, while ceramic designs can sound more forceful. These are tendencies. The magnet's size and strength, the rest of the pickup design and the distance from the strings all affect what you hear.

What to try at home

  • Measure at the output jack. On a passive guitar or bass, plug a cable into the instrument but leave the other end disconnected from the amp. Select one pickup on its own and turn its volume to 10. Set your multimeter to resistance (Ω) and touch the probes to the tip and sleeve of the free plug. The volume control can make the reading slightly lower than a measurement at the pickup leads. If it's far from the published value, check the cable, switch and wiring before blaming the pickup.

  • Compare a short and a long cable. Plug straight into a clean amp. Swap between two lengths of the same cable model without changing any settings. Listen for whether the longer cable takes some edge off the highs.

  • Check pickup height. A pickup set too far from the strings can sound weak. Note the starting height, adjust a quarter turn at a time and play the same phrase after each change.

  • Compare like with like. Compare bridge pickups with bridge pickups and neck pickups with neck pickups. Keep the amp settings the same and listen at roughly matched levels so extra volume doesn't sway the comparison.

In short

DC resistance is a useful reference for comparing similar pickups, but it doesn't tell you how loud they'll be or how they'll sound. Use it as a reference and make the final call by ear.

You can hear demos on our product pages, ask us on WhatsApp, or try guitars fitted with Vergatto pickups in Ramat Gan or Be'er Sheva.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page